logo Sign In

Info & Ideas: ESB and ROTJ Wishlist — Page 239

Author
Time

Interesting...Still believe that is too high!

Nice to see that this shot got a bit more color :)


You should note to turn off the speakers :O

 

-Angel

–>Artwork<–**

Author
Time

Bingowings said:

Once again this thread isn't exclusively for Ady (we all want to see what he is going to do with this episode but other people may do other things with it).

That would be nice. So far, seems like DE and Ady are the only ones who have done edits with extensive fixes/effects/whathaveyou. It would be great if a bunch of talented editors here could come to a consensus on what to change based on these ideas and collaborate on a mega-project!

Hey, this is a wishlist after all...

My crazy vinyl LP blog

My dumberer blog

My Retro blog

Author
Time
 (Edited)

It might be worth (once Ady's inevitable ROTJ:R thread is full swing and it's pretty clear what he definitely isn't doing) to go through threads like the ANH after Ady, Starkiller Ranch and this one and pick out all the possible changes not covered by Ady or DE and work our way through them as mini projects so the final result is a OT fan-edit identi-kit of sorts.

The process could be duplicated when Ady and hopefully a few more editors have really got under the bonnet of the PT.

Working on mini projects like that could be a great step into getting more people to do ambitious projects DE's and Ady's.

My current sig isn't a snipe at DE at all but more of a rallying cry to not let these fine ideas go to waste.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Bingowings said:

It might be worth (once Ady's inevitable ROTJ:R thread is full swing and it's pretty clear what he definitely isn't doing) to go through threads like the ANH after Ady, Starkiller Ranch and this one and pick out all the possible changes not covered by Ady or DE and work our way through them as mini projects so the final result is a OT fan-edit identi-kit of sorts.

The process could be duplicated when Ady and hopefully a few more editors have really got under the bonnet of the PT.

Working on mini projects like that could be a great step into getting more people to do ambitious projects DE's and Ady's.

My current sig isn't a snipe at DE at all but more of a rallying cry to not let these fine ideas go to waste.

I've wondered about that sig because you are one of the biggest parts of this thread, and I never read DE's quote as a challenge.

RotJR's thread is going to be a different horse.  Ady and I are going to coordinate so I have second post and I will keep the list of changes Ady is going to try to make right there, based on the Wishlist/ANHR Changes format.  I will continue to strike-through and italic things on the Wishlist that Ady is/isn't doing, leaving the Wishlist as an "unfulfilled" list to do what you suggest!

EDIT: Maybe we could have people read through the Wishlist to make sure that it hasn't already been suggested to Ady before they post something...

Star Wars Revisited Wordpress

Star Wars Visual Comparisons WordPress

Author
Time
 (Edited)

With his permission I'm using it as a bit of a rallying call because if Darth Editous hadn't done such sterling work Ady wouldn't have been inspired to do his versions and they have fed back to some extent on what DE is continuing to do.

So having him say a sentence like that shouldn't be seen as a negative, it should be seen as a sporting gauntlet thrown.

You can inspire people by delivering the goods like DE has already done and you can also inspire people with a line like that.

It makes sense to keep the wishlist alive because no one edit could do all the good ideas raised here (some are plain contradictory) and putting one to use would automatically cause others to be impossible to use (ex, you can't do the Boba Fett selling the rebels the location of the Emperor plot in a Boba free edit of ROTJ, you can't behead him or do anything with him.)

Author
Time

i'm motivated now ;)

Author
Time
 (Edited)

rcb said:

i'm motivated now ;)

Hey, *wink*, im just doing my part....

(Im beginning to think its almost futile)

Author
Time

JediMasterFisher said:

wow these Return of the Jedi images are just stunning! If this could be done to Jedi it would be amazing.

 i'm sure it's possible, with a lot of time and patience involved anyways.

Author
Time

Haven't posted here in ages, but I must say I love the Endor Test clip.

 

 

Author
Time

Palpatine's face really needs a broken exterior light source to show him off to best advantage (an analogue for moonlight through an open window).

If some could create a patterned shadow in the rough shape of some of those window frame forms and up the lighting between it would have a really spooky gothic noir look when it played across the prune faced one.

Author
Time

Palpatine's face really needs a broken exterior light source to show him off to best advantage (an analogue for moonlight through an open window).


Should it hit his eye like a big-a pizza pie?

DE

Author
Time

Darth Editous said:

 

Palpatine's face really needs a broken exterior light source to show him off to best advantage (an analogue for moonlight through an open window).

Should it hit his eye like a big-a pizza pie?
DE

 

 A Moray

That's a Moray ;-)

Author
Time

Hey bingo, i do the funnys, stick to the wishlist. But thats kind a funny

Author
Time

Bingowings said:

Palpatine's face really needs a broken exterior light source to show him off to best advantage (an analogue for moonlight through an open window).

If some could create a patterned shadow in the rough shape of some of those window frame forms and up the lighting between it would have a really spooky gothic noir look when it played across the prune faced one.

 i was thinking of something simliar

Author
Time

Eh.. My Awesome english cant put that sentence into an image..

Bingo can you make a rough mockup?

 

-Angel

–>Artwork<–**