Ryan McAvoy said:
Yeah some of todays comic artists should have read less Frank Miller when they were teenagers.
Yeah can I be honest and say i never really liked his work. I know it was groundbreaking at the time but I started reading a few years after that and I have to say I always found his artwork ugly,his stories overly dark(If that is your thing more power to you but I always enjoyed the high adventure aspect of comics more),and his treatment of woman cringe worthy. I was just never able to get into him and now we have an inter generation of writers and artists who think of him as the god of comics and it has completely turned me off mainstream american comics. You pretty much have to go to other countries or smaller comics if you want something with the same style heroics that you have in the movies.
Now please don't misunderstand me as saying that you can't tell certain types of stories in comics or that they can't get dark. I love Watchmen after all but there are limits and the darkness has to serve a purpose besides being dark because hey if something is dark that makes it better and more adult,I don't think it does. My thoughts on darkness in adventure stories are best summed up in the Red letter media review of episode 3.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ABcXyZn9xjg
Any way when i pick up a comic about say Superman or Spiderman I am looking for high adventure because let's face it those characters don't led themselves to really dark story telling. I don't want to see Superman ripping people's arms off and I don't expect to see Spiderman selling his mirage to the devil(As long as I have been reading comics Spiderman and Marry Jane were a married couple and I had stuck with them through some really bad story lines,even the clone saga,so when that happened it was the last straw for me.)
Every story doesn't have to be completely dark and devoid of hope and our heroes should be tested but in the end they should still act like heroes and not selfish nut jobs(I am looking at you civil war)and comic should never have an image like that last one in them. I have seen a lot of horror movies in my time but that just made me feel like throwing up. If you ask me the perfect comic appeals to kinds but is smart enough for adults. When I was a kid I read comics all the time but I tell you one thing if I ever have kids I will not be letting them near modern comics.
If you want to see some good comics check out All Star Superman,Tom Strong,or most of the Doctor Who comics,that is the type of comic book I wish there was more of.