
- Time
- Post link
Wow. The "polish" track - is it a real dub or a voiceover?
As of now, it is something around 18GB.
Wow. The "polish" track - is it a real dub or a voiceover?
It's a voiceover.
Also, the quality of the Portuguese 1.0 track I have is truly atrocious - doesn't anyone have a better one?
EDIT: Forget what I said about the Spanish Cast. audio, I just found out I do have a correct one as well.
Spanish Audio Latino is the one I upload ... or other?....
I think it's the one you uploaded, yes.
The Latino audio is the same, I just peak-normalized to -6dB and encoded at a lesser bitrate.
There's a less-muffled version of the Portuguese, I'll upload it in case it's different from what you have (it's still not great).
Wait a sec... I actually GOT the less-muffled version from your 2.1 release, so you've got it.
Is it SW-pt-br-1.0-TV.ac3? That's the one I've got.
chyron8472 said:
I volunteer to put it on Myspleen. I did so for v2.1.
Cheers chyron. Let us know here when it's up - I'll be watching myspleen closely tomorrow anyway - and I'll seed at 10Mbps upload too.
pittrek said:
Wow. The "polish" track - is it a real dub or a voiceover?
It's a voiceover from 1995 VHS. There are several more recent voiceovers (this one is the best of them IMO) and even a dub (made in 2011 for BD release), which is absolutely terrible. Wookiees in Holiday Special sound better than those voice actors.
So the 5.1 track will be lossless? Hairy_hen uploaded the file?
Fanrestore - Fan Restoration Forum: https://fanrestore.com
Harmy said:
Is it SW-pt-br-1.0-TV.ac3? That's the one I've got.
I'll upload the new one just to be sure.
Also, maybe it would be a good idea to include information about the year and origin of foreign audio tracks in their names. It looks cool, and probably Polish isn't the only language with multiple Star Wars dubs.
Fanrestore - Fan Restoration Forum: https://fanrestore.com
It would definitely be a good idea, if I had the information for all the tracks, but unfortunately, I don't.
Maybe CatBus has info on some of them. I'll see what I can dig up.
Fanrestore - Fan Restoration Forum: https://fanrestore.com
Well the German track is based on the GOUT (which was the 1993 track, I guess), but I've added some missing material from the theatrical version, which was 1978... so it's a bit difficult to pinpoint.
Well, so I guess you could say it's a 1978 dub reconstruction, no? Or are there some elements that were added in '93?
Since I've never heard the original 1978 track, I have no idea if there's anything else different in the 1993 track. For the German release I have labeled it as 1978 though.
Hungarian track:
From what I can tell there are two versions of the dub, with entirely different voice actors.
1984 TV dub - there probably are some bootleg recordings, because this dub seems to be really loved by Hungarians
1995 VHS dub (THX)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-JeJM_OuZvw
Comments indicate that this video is a part of 1995 version. So listen to the one you have, then the video, and you'll know. :)
Fanrestore - Fan Restoration Forum: https://fanrestore.com
Well, it seems to be different from the one I have there, but the file is named:
SW-hu-1993-2.0-VHS.ac3, which could of course very well mean that it is the 1984 dub taken from a 1993 VHS - can anyone confirm this?
The French and Spanish dubs I have are, I think from GOUT, so whichever version was on there should be it.
I'm not sure where the Japanese and Italian dubs I have came from and then I'd also need more info on the Spa-Lat and Por_Br dubs.
Hmmm, Hungarian Wikipedia says this:
A Csillagok háborúja a Mokép filmforgalmazó jóvoltából került el?ször a magyar mozikba 1979. augusztus 19.-én, ekkor még csak feliratosan vetítették. Kés?bb készítettek hozzá szinkront, melyet 1984 karácsonyán a Magyar Televízió a m?sorára t?zött. Ez a szinkron (a mai napig is) klasszikusnak számít a Magyar Star Wars rajongók és filmkedvel?k körében. 1992-ben a Guild Home Video megjelentette VHS kazettán a Csillagok háborúját az imént említett szinkronnal és egy csonkított eredeti kópiával. Ez a kiadvány kifejezetten a videó tékákban volt fellelhet?. 1995 októberében az InterCom Zrt. kiadta a trilógia "lakossági verzióját" a THX-es digitálisan felújított változatot, azonban erre a kazetta kiadványra már egy új "egységes" szinkront készítettek
Google Translate says this:
In Star Wars, the Mokép was first movie distributor, courtesy of the Hungarian theaters in 1979 . 19th August, at this time only broadcast with subtitles. He later made ??to sync with that 1984 Christmas in Hungarian Television has set the tune. This sync (to this day) classics of Hungarian Star Wars fans and movie lovers among. 1992 at the Guild Home Video has released a VHS tape of Star Wars the aforementioned sync and a truncated copy in the original. This publication is specifically designed for video tékákban could be found. 1995 in October InterCom Inc. has released a trilogy of "retail version" of THX's digitally remastered version, but this cassette publication has produced a new "uniform" in sync.
Sooo it seems that there are actually 3 versions. Original 1984, 1992 which was the previous one, but worse for some reason, and 1995, most likely the Youtube one. They used 1995 dub in 1997 special edition, I don't know about 2004 and 2011 versions, Blu-Ray has the dub in DD 5.1
Fanrestore - Fan Restoration Forum: https://fanrestore.com
The rest of the files are uploading now. My connection isn't going as consistently fast as I'd like, but they're getting there.
@Feallan: Well, that still doesn't really tell me which version is the one I have here :-/
Well, in the end credits the narrator says something about Magyar Television, so I guess it is the first one.
Harmy said:
[...]
I'm not sure where the Japanese and Italian dubs I have came from and then I'd also need more info on the Spa-Lat and Por_Br dubs.
The PT-BR Dub came from an 80's VHS.
Now, my most recent restoration of this dub is file name: "SW.Brazilian.GOUT.Sync.V2.ac3"
Do you have it?
No, I don't think so, unless it's the one CatBus just sent me, but it doesn't say v2.
@h_h: That's great! What are the bitrates of the audio tracks from you, h_h? I'm not sure MPC-HC shows the bitrates of the DTS-HDs correctly, I think it just shows the bitrate of the cores.