logo Sign In

Info: EP3 : Digital Master Artifacts?

Author
Time
 (Edited)

While scrutinizing EP3 footage from the NTSC DVD and a PAL HD capture, I detected some flaws that I normally wouldn’t expected from THX certified media.

These two instances are within a few frames of one another.
http://img167.imageshack.us/img167/3497/artifact01al8.png
http://img125.imageshack.us/img125/452/artifact02li0.png

Does the PAL DVD also present these artifacts?

If so, it would seem that the digital master is affected. Also, does anyone have any thoughts about whether these are rendering errors or compression errors?

Track the Star Wars Prologue fanedit at
Digital Fanedits
Author
Time
Those look like motion compensation artifacts to me. They're usually caused when creating "in-between"-frames (through morphing) for effects like slowing-down footage or adding motion-blur in post. Since it's a motion-blurred area, I assume the latter one.

Rendering CG-scenes with motion-blur results in longer rendering-times. Furthermore it's a lot harder to composite several elements together when they're already blurred. The usual way to deal with this, is rendering a separate "velocity"-pass of each frame (and each element... like background, foreground, individual objects...), which stores a velocity and a direction for every pixel in the frame. This allows the image to be blurred accordingly AFTER being composited.

If you don't have a velocity pass, there's still the possibility of using "motion compensated motion-blur" (there are several plugins out there doing this, and since version 7 it's included in the Pro version of AfterEffects as well), which analyzes the motion in the frame, and blurs the image based on this. Problematic areas are fast moving parts (where the difference between one frame and another is to big to be regarded as "motion"), or areas on the image's edges (where objects suddenly enter the frame, without the plugin knowing, where it was the frame before). And these "problem areas" usually cause the artifacts above.
Author
Time
You make perfect sense. I failed to connect the velocity and position clues available in these two examples.

Thanks for taking the time to explain
Track the Star Wars Prologue fanedit at
Digital Fanedits