logo Sign In

Cutnshut's Jedi (* unfinished project *)

Author
Time
 (Edited)

This weekend I started my own edit of Return of the Jedi :p

OMG not another jedi edit! yeah i know theres a few in the works now but it was either this or episode 1…

this is the first time i’ve ever tried editing and thought it was about time i tried it.

…I’ve used Womble and following ADM’s editing guide managed to produce the first 9 minutes of a movie! wow…

heres the link:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NzridF3ZJQs

list of changes:

  • removed the opening crawl from the movie. I’ve heard the opening star wars theme too many times over the years and wanted to avoid using it in my edit. I thought it would be nice to see a star wars film start differently.

I like the opening credit sequence to Alien 3 so used that as a guide here.

  • The Empire is cut from the beginning of the movie it will be used later on.

  • The movie now starts at Jabba’s Palace - I wanted the opening sequence to be darker in spirit and have a more mysterious tone to it.

  • Changed the music where ever possible for some reason…

  • cut out C3PO’s wailing, it’s about time he became braver! and don’t say its not in his programming!

  • Jabba now speaks less and there is no need for subtitles as 3PO translates what you need to know.

  • Some cuts in Lukes holo message to Jabba - he’s more to the point now

  • no more eve99 or whatever the hell droid it is… it just wasted time and cut from the main plot at this point.

  • Cut the music number and party antics

the video ends after Chewbacca is (seeming…) captured… oooh

This will be the end of the opening credits and then the next scene would be off to dagobah to introduce luke. I kinda stole the idea for this off Spence (i think, well i know thats what someone was going to do in their edit)… Good idea there 😃

so thats the next thing ill be doing…

anyway hope you like my video and let me know what you think!

You can never go home again, but i guess you can shop there.

Author
Time

The titles felt really intrusive, and it felt relatively dull for the beginning of a Star Wars movie.  It's an interesting concept, just not my kinda thing, personally.

Author
Time

good first attempt, and i see what you're doing. i liked the voice in the dark, but that could have been an opportunity to put in some reminders from ESB. music was good too (what was it?)

agree with rpvee, a bit blunt with the cuts, although i wouldnt worry about the dullness. ROTJ sort of begins with the slow hangover after the binge that was ESB.

have a crack at reopening all the films? each one would demand a different flavour.

star wars but not star wars.

Author
Time

watch the typefaces too. the names work, the subtitles really dont.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Thanks for your comments already!

hmm, yeah it doesnt quite work - think i'll try something else.

As for the music is from Shadows of the Empire soundtrack CD (Joel McNeely,1996).

 

 

 

 

 

 

You can never go home again, but i guess you can shop there.

Author
Time

It's definitely a neat concept, I don't like it better than the original way, but I like seeing alternatives even if it doesn't become my preffered version.

If you need any editing program help, let me know.

Author
Time

I understand you're trying to do something fresh. I really get that, and can work for some eyes. At the end of the day make sure you're making it the way you want to. I take advice, but if I disagree, I disagree. Because in the end, it's what I want to see.

Now as far as what I think, I started to like it, but then it got old going back to black. Have you thought of taking an Indiana Jones title approach? I don't know, it's just what I saw in my head.

Keep plugging along man. You never know, this could be one of the better edits out there when you get done with it.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Thanks for the encouragement - I'll see how it goes, when i started the opening credits I had a clear goal in mind but after i got editing i realised I couldnt cut too much out of jabba's palace or the plot would be broken - and then made the credits go on for too long.

I dismissed it originally, but I like Ben_Dangers idea of incorporating some flash backs from Empire Strikes Back.

Im not trying to improve Return of the Jedi im just making an alternative version.

I need to plan out what i want to do and experiment to work out what will and won't work.

I will have a look at the Indiana Jones credits to see how they work without fading to black. Im also a big fan of TMBTM's War of the Stars, so i'll have a look at how he used credits as well.

You can never go home again, but i guess you can shop there.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

I've heard in the Radio Drama for Return of the Jedi there are some extended scenes - does anyone know what they are?

thanks

edit: not needed now.

 

 

You can never go home again, but i guess you can shop there.

Author
Time

Hey Cn'S.  How is this coming along?