logo Sign In

Do You Remember...the Thrawn Trilogy?

Author
Time

I’ve been re-reading the Heir to the Empire trilogy recently, and I can’t help but view it with a more critical eye. Many parts of the trilogy feel half-baked, like it was published as a first draft. So in no particular order I will give my thoughts on aspects of the story that I feel like could have used more time in the oven and give some ideas for how another draft could have improved them.

You probably don’t recognize me because of the red arm.
Episode 9 Rewrite, The Starlight Project (Released!) and Terminator Ultimatum,

Author
Time

Luke’s Loneliness

Scene 1 - At the beginning of Heir to the Empire, Ben’s spirit visits Luke for the last time. When Luke awakens, it is to the grief of knowing that he is now fully alone, the sole source of knowledge and wisdom for the generations of Jedi that are to follow him. It’s a good scene, but the rest of the book doesn’t really do anything with it. Luke is not focused on training the next generation of Jedi, and the one potential Jedi that he has been training - Leia - doesn’t have time for it at the moment anyway.

Scene 2 - It is only in Dark Force Rising that we get a scene where Luke’s lack of a comprehensive Jedi education becomes important, and it is actually one of my favorite scenes of the trilogy. In it, Luke mediates a dispute between two patrons in a bar, successfully finding a solution in what feels like an inversion of the altercation from A New Hope in the Mos Eisley Cantina. As much as I love this scene from a worldbuilding perspective (The galaxy’s inhabitants instinctively defer to the Jedi to act as judges and respect their judgment), the issue here is that Luke is successful despite his lack of Jedi training.

Scene 3 - Later in the novel, Luke decides to visit the long-lost Jedi Master Jorus C’baoth, questioning why he is taking time out of his busy schedule for this unlikely venture to meet with a man who may easily be a Dark Jedi or lead into an Imperial trap.

Here we have three scenes that could describe a compelling character journey, but instead feel vague, wayward, unfocused. Let us instead imagine a different set of scenes:

Scene 1 - While Han and Leia are struggling to recruit worlds into the fledgling New Republic, Luke has journeyed across the galaxy seeking any source of Jedi teachings that hasn’t been destroyed by the Empire. On planet after planet, the dwellings and temples of the Jedi have been burned, ransacked, pummeled from orbit by Star Destroyers, and generally turned to ash and dust. Nevertheless, Luke holds out hope for one on the edge of New Republic space. He travels there, finding it mostly intact, until he goes inside and sees that some Dark Jedi has destroyed everything of value and desecrated what remains. He leaves the temple, reporting to R2 that it’s the same situation that he saw on Olfir, Tengriss, Coruscant. He is about to leave when a boy from the nearby village runs to Luke and asks for his help. An old woman in the village is in pain. Luke follows the boy to the old woman’s hut, offering her medications from his X-wing supply, but she waves them away, saying that she came here because none of the Republic’s medicines could help her. She knew the Jedi Master that lived here, and oftentimes he would minister to her, easing her pain with the ways of the Force. The old woman asks if Luke is here in answer to her prayers, for she has had so many painful nights since the Jedi disappeared. Luke lays his hands on her in the way she describes the Jedi Master had so often done, but Luke is unable to help her. She tells him that it is not his fault, but Luke nevertheless feels the pain of defeat. He promises to return once he has found some way to help her, but she says not to make promises that he cannot keep, for without a Jedi Master to teach Luke, there are things he can never learn. Not from books or lore, anyway.

Scene 2 - At the beginning of Dark Force Rising, Luke returns to Coruscant into a political maelstrom. The Bothan faction opposing Mon Mothma and Ackbar proclaims that the Bims have rejected the offer of Republic protection and sided with the Empire because Luke was unable to protect them. The Bothans ask why Luke hasn’t begun training a new generation of Jedi that the New Republic desperately needs, and Luke responds that he isn’t yet a master, and to train more Jedi prematurely would risk creating more Dark Jedi. The Bothans propose a solution to this problem. They will enlist the aid of one Jorus C’baoth, a Jedi Master long rumored to be dead but now apparently alive and returned to his home planet of Jormark after years lost in the unknown reaches of the galaxy. The Bothans believe that he is the answer to their problem, and they are already planning to bring him to Coruscant to train the Force-sensitive youths that they have identified in the five years since the battle of Endor. Luke objects, claiming that this is clearly an Imperial ploy, but they are undeterred. Luke then offers to himself go and determine if this Jorus C’baoth is truly who he claims to be.

Scene 3 - Luke discusses his plan with Han and Leia. They are none too keen, but by now Luke can’t help but hope that the Bothans are right and this man is truly a long-lost Jedi master. His research shows that Jorus C’baoth was a polyglot, studied in all the disciplines of the Jedi, particularly Jedi healing, so even if he was turned to the Dark Side, he would be a valuable source of information. Luke leaves for Jormark with hope that he can fulfil his promise and save the New Republic from falling into chaos.

You probably don’t recognize me because of the red arm.
Episode 9 Rewrite, The Starlight Project (Released!) and Terminator Ultimatum,