I am working on upgrading/expanding/completing the Special Edition visual changes for eventual use on savestarwars.com, but figured I’d share it outside of that thread for those interested. I used WookieGroomer’s Splitscreen 1080p wmv to take the frame-by-frame shots, and msycamore provided the 1997 screencaps.
Star Wars 1977/2011
I’m still tweaking it, especially the text. Please submit suggestions for possible text and let me know if I missed anything.
The most interesting thing we’ve noticed is that each wipe from 2004 starts early enough to cover up the original optical wipe and the fades from black start a lot later, almost as if they were trying to cover up the original wipes instead of recreating them. This goes against all previously known facts about the wipes.
EMPIRE STRIKES BACK:
Empire Strikes Back 1980/2011
RETURN OF THE JEDI:
Return of the Jedi 1983/2011
JEDIT: All links are to the final versions.
JEDIT 2: You can also find all the links on http://starwarsviscomp.doubleofive.com
Additional sources of information on many of the changes made to the Original Trilogy films over the years:-
‘Star Wars Special Edition Visual Comparisons’ - twitter page by doubleofive
‘Star Wars Special Edition Visual Comparisons’ - blog by doubleofive; as linked to above, with image pages for SW : ESB : ROTJ
StarWars•com Official 1997 Changes Articles : SW: SE : ESB: SE : ROTJ: SE - via the Internet Archive’s WayBack Machine website
StarWars•com Official 2004 Changes Preservation : SW : ESB : ROTJ - compiled by doubleofive
A helpful overview of the changes to the OT - and surrounding issues - from zombie84’s SaveStarWars•com’s FAQ Page
‘Special Edition Changes’ - 2010 article on the changes made for the 2004 DVD release - from zombie84’s SaveStarWars•com
‘All Changes Made To Star Wars’ (Original Trilogy) - YouTube Videos by Marcelo Zuniga : SW - Part 1 : SW - Part 2 : ESB : ROTJ
DVDActive•com’s (& OT member Mentasm) ‘Star Wars - The Changes’ articles (via Web•Archive•org) - SW : ESB : ROTJ : The Prequels
‘The Big List of Changes to the SW films’ OT•com thread on the FromScriptToDVD site’s comparison articles - by Gregatron
‘Who Shot First? The Complete List Of Star Wars Changes’ - an Empire film magazine article
Wookieepedia’s ‘List of changes in Star Wars re-releases’ page
‘List of changes in Star Wars re-releases’ - from the IPFS•io website
Star Wars Comparison’s YouTube video channel for comparing theatrical cuts to official blu ray and various fan projects.
and also reading through these superb OT•com threads (by doubleofive):-
’Sources on the Special Edition’ - in the Theatrical Cuts vs. Subsequent Releases section of the site.
’Modern SE Revisionism’ - in the Theatrical Cuts vs. Subsequent Releases section of the site.
these two discussion threads on the issue of uncorrected mistakes that still feature in the official Special Edition releases:-
You’d think they’d clean this up… - uncorrected mistakes (2004 OT DVD release thread)
What HASN’T been changed on Blu-ray – the uncorrected mistakes of Star Wars (2011 OT Blu ray release thread)
as well as these Index Threads which link to many topics of discussion here on the OT•com regarding the changes made to the Original Trilogy films:-
An Index Thread for Theatrical Cuts vs. Subsequent Releases…
An Index Thread for General Star Wars Discussion…
plus these two similarly related threads, pinned in the General Star Wars Discussion section of the site…
An OriginalTrilogy.com timeline thread - a history of the site and why & how it came to be…
George Lucas: Unreliable Narrator & Time Travelling Revisionist…
If you know of any suitable and quality articles, videos or links to be added to those listed above, please post them in here.
Also, if you see any broken links or errors please also post them in here too - thank you.
Last updated - 3rd August, 2019.
If you are new to the OriginalTrilogy•com then the following info may be of some assistance…
The Welcome to the OT.com; Introduce yourself in here - a good place to make your first post is just that; a place to make your first post on here - and for more longstanding members to welcome new additions to our community.
Secondly, the About and Help sections may be of interest to you regarding this site and what the OriginalTrilogy•com is about.
Thirdly, the ’How do I do this?’ on the OriginalTrilogy.com - some info & answers to members’ queries thread should also hopefully be of some help as to many of the functions of the site, along with other related info as well.
The Announcements Section - including Site Rules & Guidelines, Fan Edit & Preservation Rules & FAQ, as well info for Signatures, Linking Policy for Downloads, and Plot Spoiler Policy (and much more) that may be of use too.
If you are having any issues with the site, have a question, an idea to improve the site, or would like to give some feedback - then these can be done in the Feedback Forum and General Assistance sections.
There are also several Index Threads pinned at the top of many respective sections of the OT•com - which may help members find various topics of discussion, fan edits, preservations and other projects etc.
To Join the OT.com Discord server! click on the link. There is also the OriginalTrilogy.com Twitter too.
’An OriginalTrilogy.com timeline thread - a history of the site and why & how it came to be…’ chronicles both the history of this site & also it’s continuing evolution.
Finally, the ’George Lucas: Unreliable Narrator & Time Travelling Revisionist…' thread attempts to highlight and catalogue some of the revisionism, altering of history and contradictory claims by George Lucas / Lucasfilm as to the formation, planning and history of the Star Wars films and universe therein.
“005 is super hep” - dahmage
Star Wars Revisited Wordpress / Facebook / Twitter
005’s List of List & Comparisons