Sign In

Clone Wars Movie Series — Page 15

Author
Time

MalàStrana said:

Is there a quality difference between the 1080p version and the bluray version by the way ? Usually I take the bluray version for the extras and a better video-audio quality, but bigger doesn’t always mean better. Just to know.

That’s being said, I would love a link to get Ep I and “fixed” Ep IV bluray 😃

Looks better on bigger TV screens.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Ok ! What else has been changed to Ep IV aside from the audio track and the repetitive shot removed ? The video file seems 2 minutes longer than the previous version (I need to resync my french subtitle file, so just to know where to look to alter it easily).

As for Episode V, I haven’t got time to watch it yet, but it consists of 6 main episodes + stuff from other episodes ?

(Nightsisters, Monster, Witches of the Mist, Massacre, Bounty, Brothers, Revenge, and Revival, right ?)

“I have to say that I felt George’s group of six films had more innovative visual imagination, and this film was more of a retrenchment to things you had seen before and characters you had seen before, and it took a few baby steps forward with new characters.” - James Cameron about Episode VII.

Author
Time

I watched Episode V on Vimeo.

It’s frakking epic !

The focused plot and the intrinsic qualities of the arc help a lot, but what a ride.

Congrats, Smudger !

Author
Time

I must admit I’m not as convinced as I was for the first 4 edit-movies. The middle part doesn’t work that well, too many dialogues still contain the time factor that time has been passing by, but the idea of making everything happening in a row is very good though, I just think more should have been cut to accomodate it. The same goes with spider-Maul, maybe trimming more to directly make the encounter with Savage happen in the main lair (which means getting rid of the fight and most of the Lord of the rings 3 rip-off) would have been better. And I kinda miss the fact that the story goes too far away from Ventress and that we don’t get to see more of her bounty hunter life. It seems kinda dry without that substory, especially since it’s quite important in the season 5 finale. I believe cutting more of the repetitive stuff would have allowed the running time to contain more of the Ventress bounty hunter material, which should get the focus on. Maul, Savage, even Dooku aren’t very interesting. Ventress and the nightsisters are.

Sorry for the mixed review Smudger 😕

“I have to say that I felt George’s group of six films had more innovative visual imagination, and this film was more of a retrenchment to things you had seen before and characters you had seen before, and it took a few baby steps forward with new characters.” - James Cameron about Episode VII.

Author
Time

MalàStrana said:

I must admit I’m not as convinced as I was for the first 4 edit-movies. The middle part doesn’t work that well, too many dialogues still contain the time factor that time has been passing by, but the idea of making everything happening in a row is very good though, I just think more should have been cut to accomodate it. The same goes with spider-Maul, maybe trimming more to directly make the encounter with Savage happen in the main lair (which means getting rid of the fight and most of the Lord of the rings 3 rip-off) would have been better. And I kinda miss the fact that the story goes too far away from Ventress and that we don’t get to see more of her bounty hunter life. It seems kinda dry without that substory, especially since it’s quite important in the season 5 finale. I believe cutting more of the repetitive stuff would have allowed the running time to contain more of the Ventress bounty hunter material, which should get the focus on. Maul, Savage, even Dooku aren’t very interesting. Ventress and the nightsisters are.

Sorry for the mixed review Smudger 😕

No need to apologize!

I looked long and hard at the Ventress bounty episode, but the fact that it’s a totally separate story made it impossible to include whilst maintaining a flowing narrative. So in the end I compromised by just including the two cantina scenes, which at least shows you what she’s up to post Dathomir.

As for the Maul/Savage stuff. I cut the fire breathers scene and trimmed Maul’s introduction. Trimming more would have affected the pacing IMO.

Author
Time

smudger9 said:

MalàStrana said:

I must admit I’m not as convinced as I was for the first 4 edit-movies. The middle part doesn’t work that well, too many dialogues still contain the time factor that time has been passing by, but the idea of making everything happening in a row is very good though, I just think more should have been cut to accomodate it. The same goes with spider-Maul, maybe trimming more to directly make the encounter with Savage happen in the main lair (which means getting rid of the fight and most of the Lord of the rings 3 rip-off) would have been better. And I kinda miss the fact that the story goes too far away from Ventress and that we don’t get to see more of her bounty hunter life. It seems kinda dry without that substory, especially since it’s quite important in the season 5 finale. I believe cutting more of the repetitive stuff would have allowed the running time to contain more of the Ventress bounty hunter material, which should get the focus on. Maul, Savage, even Dooku aren’t very interesting. Ventress and the nightsisters are.

Sorry for the mixed review Smudger 😕

No need to apologize!

I looked long and hard at the Ventress bounty episode, but the fact that it’s a totally separate story made it impossible to include whilst maintaining a flowing narrative. So in the end I compromised by just including the two cantina scenes, which at least shows you what she’s up to post Dathomir.

As for the Maul/Savage stuff. I cut the fire breathers scene and trimmed Maul’s introduction. Trimming more would have affected the pacing IMO.

Yeah you shouldn’t feel bad, you could always pull out the old blurays if you wanna catch up on those stories. It’s not like there being taken away. 😉 This is just Lucky Charms without all the purple horseshoes when the original is still in the breakfast aisle. 😃

Author
Time

I was wondering Smudger, if you ever planned to make new cover art for episode 1 2 and 3?

I like the new format for covers, but the 3 disembodied heads really clash with the two new ones.

Of course if anyone else has made custom covers and is willing to share, I’d like to see them too.

=====================
I like the prequels
just as much as the OT

Author
Time

Just now came looking to see if Ep V was out yet.

…And score! Downloading from the Spleen now.

TV’s Frink said:

chyron just put a big Ric pic in your sig and be done with it.

Author
Time

MalàStrana said:

Is there a quality difference between the 1080p version and the bluray version by the way ? Usually I take the bluray version for the extras and a better video-audio quality, but bigger doesn’t always mean better. Just to know.

That’s being said, I would love a link to get Ep I and “fixed” Ep IV bluray 😃

Me and the boys are pumped for this, yes episode I, yes late to the party, but still pumped after the trailer. We tried the BluRay version, but always got hit with an error of an incomplete archive (@165). 1080 is working, though. Thanks smudger!

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Hey all I’ve bee trying to find episode 4 and 5 of smudgers awesome edits. (ep 4 fan edit link down) and can’t seen to get a reply from smudger, just wondering if anyone could point me in the right direction
Nelic182@hotmail.com

Thanks all!

Edit:all good Just grabbed vimeo versions cheers!

Ash

Author
Time

smudger9 said:

hansolo8004 said:

Whatever happened to this?  Anything?  I’ve been looking everywhere and it’s not uploaded yet.

I haven’t watched the Clone Wars because of the childish aspect to it, so really looking forward to this!

It’s now available. The download files will be up on Fanedit.info on Monday. If you cant wait that long PM me your email and I’ll send you the file for JDownloader.

Alternatively there is a streamable version on vimeo. Password is my username.

Smudger9,I would be so grateful if tou could email links of ant full movie SW edits youve created

Author
Time

i pm smudger9 on fanedit, no reply…hmmm…

looking for those cuts too

philipp

Author
Time

Episodes I to V may well be available on FanEdit•info (as smudger stated). If not, or there is an error, it may be worth reporting it at FanEdit•info - or asking them to re-upload them.

originaltrilogy.com Moderator

Why don’t you knock it off with them negative waves? Why don’t you dig how beautiful it is out here?
And say something righteous and hopeful for a change?