Sign In

Chronologically Lost HD (Remaster of Mike Maloney's edit) [FINISHED] — Page 4

Author
Time

Hi! I’d love to give this a go.
Just today I decided to re-watch LOST with my SO and this seems like the perfect thing.
Can you send me info in PM? Thanks!!!

Author
Time

I’ve been searching for this forever! Please hook me up with a download link OP

Author
Time

I’ve been on a LOST clips binge and found my way here. I’d love the link as well if possible!

Author
Time

may i have the links please? thanks for all effort. if only i saw this weeks ago under quarantine. my stayathome days would be much more enjoyable. thanks again.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

i just started watching this and it was great till end of the episode 1. i didnt understand what happened. i would rather watch these scenes after i watched the before scenes. i guess causelogical order wouldve been much better for this kinda series.

jacob and his brothers and their mothers and the people scenes were perfect. i almost didnt remember any of it. it was like a new series for me. loved it this way.

1 question: to watch it my way, where should i keep watching from now?

edit: after skip last part of episode 1, it was okay again with episode 2. i’ll write down the part i skipped later.

Author
Time

This sounds great. I’d love to have the link. Thanks for doing this.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

ozgun14 said:

i just started watching this and it was great till end of the episode 1. i didnt understand what happened. i would rather watch these scenes after i watched the before scenes. i guess causelogical order wouldve been much better for this kinda series.

jacob and his brothers and their mothers and the people scenes were perfect. i almost didnt remember any of it. it was like a new series for me. loved it this way.

1 question: to watch it my way, where should i keep watching from now?

edit: after skip last part of episode 1, it was okay again with episode 2. i’ll write down the part i skipped later.

Yeah, it will feel disjointed in areas when the scenes have been rearranged. The edits really more for the curiosity and to offer something different than the intended order. I remember seeing some discussion on the placement of that timeflash about whether it should have been earlier in the episode (but it definitely had to be before episode 2 cause of the statue being intact that got demolished by the Black Rock) and whether Locke’s side in the well should have been in the future.

Sorry, just caught your message, Geauxlden eagle. PM sent.

FINISHED Projects: Chronologically LOST HD

Youtube Profile

Author
Time

Just watched the 1st episode. I’m hooked. Thank you very much.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

i finished watching it days ago. thanks for the effort. it totally worth it. it was great in total but like i said, timeshifts and 1974-1977 shouldve been after 2004.

my suggestion is:
1-3 (beginning-1972) island, two brothers, richard, dharma
9-79 (1978-2004) all characters flashbacks, others early years, flight, accident, all island things, teleportation
80-88 (2005-2007) the ones with leave the island, second flight, accident, after accident
all the timeshifts + 4 (1974-1977) the ones with stay on the island
5-8 (1977) everyone on the same page with oceanic team back and explosion
89-96 (2007) after explosion everyone on the same page again
97-101 (epilogue)

tbh, its not easy to locate timeshifts (there are fourteen of them.)

Author
Time

ozgun14 said:

i finished watching it days ago. thanks for the effort. it totally worth it. it was great in total but like i said, timeshifts and 1974-1977 shouldve been after 2004.

my suggestion is:
1-3 (beginning-1972) island, two brothers, richard, dharma
9-79 (1978-2004) all characters flashbacks, others early years, flight, accident, all island things, teleportation
80-88 (2005-2007) the ones with leave the island, second flight, accident, after accident
all the timeshifts + 4 (1974-1977) the ones with stay on the island
5-8 (1977) everyone on the same page with oceanic team back and explosion
89-96 (2007) after explosion everyone on the same page again
97-101 (epilogue)

tbh, its not easy to locate timeshifts (there are fourteen of them.)

Cheers. I can see where you’re going with it, though this edit (along with the original version) was aiming to be a more literally in order of time, so it was gonna be out of place, definitely not a way to introduce someone to the series.

FINISHED Projects: Chronologically LOST HD

Youtube Profile

Author
Time

thanks again, you made me watch this masterpiece again. it was an amazing journey first time, and second is nothing less.

Author
Time

Hi!
A comment in an article on Lost mentioned the Chronological edit, and a search led me to this message board.

The work the original fan editor and you did sounds awesome; I’d love to watch this edit (I won’t have time for a while, though).
May I have a link to the download page, please?

This looks like an interesting place, too.
Incidentally, I watched the first Star Wars again a few days ago and will watch The Empire Strikes Back this evening.
As for Lost, however much I’d love to watch it again, particularly in chronological order of events, the best I can afford to do right now is listen to the music.

All the best,

Olivier

Author
Time

Thanks again, DragoonClawNZ.
Mighty kind and swift and you.
😃

Author
Time

Hi! I’m watching it now and I have a few things to notice:

  • First, the editing it’s absolutely stunning, it’s a really great work! Good job!
  • In episode 010 around 23:30, while Desmond and Penny are talking, it happens a few times that the screen goes fully black, while the audio is still going, I think it’s a technical problem, as it happens when streaming for google drive
  • I noticed that you put Desmond’s “mind-travel” to 1996 in episode 058 and not in episodes 011-012… May I ask why? As it is now there’s a hole where Desmond and Penny take their photo and when Desmond leaves her.
Author
Time

Thanks, Rant423.

The screen going black was intentional, it was when it intercut with the events where they cut Naomi out of the tree, no other way of doing it sadly. It also happens later when Ben and Juliet are discussing her infiltration into the survivors camp.

Not the first time it was brought up, there was an explanation for that, even on the original site. The way I see that “mind-travel” is that it’s happening inside his head as opposed to actually going back (like in The Constant), but also from a technical side, it would be tough to edit it in cause it shows glimpses of the island events (which would be odd to see if we didn’t see them already), and for Charlie when the rain hits is completely different between that and his flashback (where Desmond isn’t there and he then saves Nadia from muggers). So I left it as is for this remaster.

FINISHED Projects: Chronologically LOST HD

Youtube Profile

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Thanks for the answer!

About the screen going black, I didn’t remember how it was on the original, it makes sense now.

About Desmond, I disagree and I think that his flashes from the future are in his head, but the whole travel to 1996 actually happened (about Charlie - he is wearing a different outfit, I think it’s just another day).

But then - you’re the one that took on the job of doing this monumental work, so I’m not complaining that much lol.

Thanks again!

P.S. I see that it has been exactly one year from the original post, happy anniversary!