logo Sign In

Are Improved/Remastered versions of the Plinkett prequel reviews on anyone's radar?

Author
Time

I’m wondering if a “remaster” of the Plinkett reviews from RedLetter Media are on anyone’s radar? How would I even request such a thing – and to who? These are true (in my opinion) pieces of Star Wars history. Nothing has ever so perfectly encapsulated everything wrong with a film series than these reviews:

Here’s a playlist:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxKtZmQgxrI&list=PLZJ2yOBfQ1hr3wacUOgHhY_ZFZ2ujxAEo

The only issue is that they’re super old YouTube videos. One day they’ll be gone. Even if they’re around forever, they’re crappy VHS/DVD quality. How do I go about proposing a “fan edit” of these reviews?

Author
Time
 (Edited)

IMO, they (the Plinkett rantings) symbolize everything that has gone wrong with Star Wars fandom and fandom and basically the entire internet in general and perhaps best just show how little he knows of the history of cinema and he gets TONS of stuff flat out objectively incorrect. They basically ended SW discussion forums as a fun place. And ended serious criticism and swapped it for cheap click-bait. Anyway I better get my bunker prepped.

That said I’m sure you’ll get plenty of takers (except it isn’t all that possible to remaster the parts where he appears, since he probably just shot on VHS, on the odd chance he shot on SVHS or Hi8 or some super early digital format, maybe something a little bit more could be done though; the scenes from the films could get swapped in with footage from blu-ray or scans, but it seems weird to me that people who so despise the films would want to waste hours beyond hours of time pasting in higher quality footage of scenes of stuff they don’t care for? does it matter if the scenes look like compressed trash if the scenes are being mocked and considered to be trash anyway?).

Author
Time

I’m pretty sure someone has already done this. Someone on this very forum, but I can’t remember who. I have them downloaded at home. I am out of town this week but will see if I can PM them to you when I get back!

“I speak Spanish!”

Author
Time

rodserling27 said:

I’m pretty sure someone has already done this. Someone on this very forum, but I can’t remember who. I have them downloaded at home. I am out of town this week but will see if I can PM them to you when I get back!

Amazing, absolutely amazing. If you have them, I don’t even know what to say – happiest I’ll have been in a looooong time!

Author
Time

MonkeyLizard10 said:

IMO, they symbolize everything that has gone wrong with Star Wars fandom and fandom and basically the entire internet in general and perhaps best just show how little he knows of the history of cinema. They basically ended SW discussion forums as a fun place. And ended serious criticism and swapped it for cheap click-bait. Anyway I better get my bunker prepped.

That said I’m sure you’ll get plenty of takers (except it isn’t all that possible to remaster the parts where he appears, since he probably just shot on VHS, on the odd chance he shot on SVHS or Hi8 or some super early digital format, maybe something a little bit more could be done though; the scenes from the films could get swapped in with footage from blu-ray or scans, but it seems weird to me that people who so despise the films would want to waste hours beyond hours of time pasting in higher quality footage of scenes of stuff they don’t care for? does it matter if the scenes look like compressed trash if the scenes are being mocked and considered to be trash anyway?).

“they symbolize everything that has gone wrong with Star Wars fandom”

When you say “they”, are you talking about the reviews, or the films? I don’t understand how a “fan” of star wars wouldn’t be completely let down (disgusted, even) by that money grab from 1999 - 2005. A story that never needed to be told that arguably makes the OT worse. I don’t want to get into a big debate about it here, but the Plinkett reviews are maybe the best example of someone transcribing my thoughts on those films I think I’ve ever experienced.

Sorry for disagreeing – I appreciate the comment!

Author
Time
 (Edited)

There’s something called ‘Red Letter Media’ Archival Project’ on Myspleen. I just downloaded the prequel reviews from it and they’re 1080p. I’ll share them if you want me to.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

stretch009 said:

There’s something called ‘Red Letter Media’ Archival Project’ on Myspleen. I just downloaded the prequel reviews from it and they’re 1080p. I’ll share them if you want me to.

I’m trying to recover my myspleen account anyway for me to do it?

Author
Time

From what I’ve gathered you have to use IRC, so google - myspleen irc.

Author
Time

stretch009 said:

From what I’ve gathered you have to use IRC, so google - myspleen irc.

How do you get a myspleen to begin with?