logo Sign In

All Things Star Trek — Page 43

Author
Time

My coworker, who was once finance manager to the Prime Minister of New Guinea, told me, without ever referencing Star Trek, the first ever decent defense of the Prime Directive. 

The people of New Guinea were told the value of a Western style education. so villages would save up to send one bright young man out to get an education, then to send money back to the village.

These young men would leave school brilliant, but unable to do anything in the largely non-industrial country. Consequently, to save face and repay their village, they mainly turned to crime.  

A whole sub class of young, educated criminals infested every city, where previously urban crime was almost non-existant. 

Author
Time
 (Edited)

SAAVIK : Humour. it is a difficult concept, it is not logical.

SPOCK : Litigation has numerous potential benefits.

BONES : Speaking as a physician but no expert on that Vulcan physiognomy of yours but wouldn't a glass of lager have the opposite effect?

SPOCK : No

SAAVIK : Yes

SPOCK : NO

SAAVIK : YES!

KIRK : Now you know why Romulan Ale is illegal.

Author
Time

twister111 said:

pittrek said:

One technical question for you guys.



Why does season 4 of Enterprise looks so HORRIBLY WRONG? What happened? I know they changed from 35mm film to 1080p digital Sony cameras, but that doesn't explain why everything looks and moves so weird...

To my understanding they were still figuring out the best way to make those cameras. So it likely boils down to the construction of the camera itself. Nothing the film crew could do about that.

Slightly unrelated but it reminds me how around that time the very chemical formula to develop film prints was changed from the old way. It was in order to give truer black levels to the image.

http://img687.imageshack.us/img687/7405/cooly.gif

 RIP celluloid :(!

“What Orwell feared were those who would ban books. What Huxley feared was that there would be no reason to ban a book, for there would be no one who wanted to read one.”

Neil Postman, Amusing Ourselves to Death

Author
Time
 (Edited)

DrCrowTStarwars said:

Mike O said:

DrCrowTStarwars said:

Yeah that is what killed Voyager for me. I could have put up with some of the stupid stuff but when a show seems to forget what it's own premise is from week to week,then it loses me.  They never ran out of shuttles,or people,and no matter what went wrong it was always fixed next week. For a show that was supposed to be about being out on the edge and not having any back up they sure did play it safe.  That is just sad. Voyager could have been the best Star Trek series and instead it is the only one I can not stand. Yes you read that right. There are parts of Enterprise that I like but Voyager's forgetfulness of it's own basic premise pushes it over the top for me.

If it were not for Holo Doc I don't think I could have stuck with it for seven years.

 A friend of mine pointed out that the premise Voyager initially promised is actually more like what BSG eventually became: dark, ragtag ship on the run, etc. Is the new BSG series any good, by the way? It's up on Netflix, I'm curious. 

 Yes it is.  I don't think it is the best sci-fi series of all time(I think they some times fell into the trap of making things dark for no other reason then making them dark and there were some soap opera elements in the latter seasons I didn't care for)but it is still a very good show and right off the bat I said to myself "This is the show Voyager should have been." There is a ton of good in the show(Even if some of the plot elements don't make sense) and I would say that everyone who is a sci-fi fan should give it a shot. Be warned it is a little like Lost in that nothing was planed from the start(You know I am starting to think B5 was the only sci-fi show that's plot arc was planed in any detail)so there are a few things that are never completely explained or when they are explained seem a little silly.  Still if you can over look that I would say watch it.  It is a very well done show and is very close to how Voyager should have been done. Check it out.

 Sadly, B5 appears to be streaming absolutely nowhere. Which is a shame, since it can't grow an audience, and it damn sure isn't getting remastered as a result.  I've not seen it yet for said reason, either.

pittrek said:

One technical question for you guys.

Why does season 4 of Enterprise looks so HORRIBLY WRONG? What happened? I know they changed from 35mm film to 1080p digital Sony cameras, but that doesn't explain why everything looks and moves so weird...

For 3 years of TOS, 7 years of TNG, 7 years of DS9, 7 years of VOY and 3 years on ENT we were used to the typical 35mm film @ 24fps -> video @ 30fps (or in my European case 25fps) look. Everything looked a certain way, everybody moved in a certain speed... Now suddenly everything looks like the Hobbit movies! The movement looks "faster", more "smoother" etc. I don't know if you guys know what I'm talking about but I hope at least somebody does.

I noticed the "effect" for the first time in 2006/7 when they broadcast Enterprise season 4 on TV here. I read online that they changed from film to digital, so I thought something went horribly wrong when they converted the footage from NTSC to PAL, that they've done something bad to the framerate and that's the reason why everything looks "faster". But now after I watched the whole season 4 on bluray I'm even more confused, the bluray videos run at 24fps, and the effect seems even more noticable and even more disturbing! It goes so far that I can't watch a whole damned episode without having breaks every couple of minutes. Or does it have to do something with the fact that the episodes suck? I don't know, but the overall effect is REALLY annoying and distracting.

Does anybody know what they did? I always thought that they filmed season 4 at 1080p/24fps. Now I actually start to think they filmed it in 1080i/60fps or something similar.

 Back in the day, were TV shows shot at 24 FPS and then converted to 30 FPS for NTSC broadcast via pulldown?

“What Orwell feared were those who would ban books. What Huxley feared was that there would be no reason to ban a book, for there would be no one who wanted to read one.”

Neil Postman, Amusing Ourselves to Death

Author
Time

Yeah the way Warner Brothers treats B5 is a disgrace.  It didn't become as big as Star Trek after five years so they just gave up on it and now the show is slowly dying.  It's why I am backing up my Dvds so that if they ever go i will still have the show somewhere.  Finding the DvDs is becoming hard,that is one reason I would not hold it against anyone if they torrented the show. It's a shame because i think it was remastered B5 would find new viewers.

Author
Time

Technically well done, but I'm still going to have nightmares. ;)

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time

A sausage sliding into Picard's ear ... I thought something like that could only happen in bad fanfiction.

Author
Time

DuracellEnergizer said:

A sausage sliding into Picard's ear ... I thought something like that could only happen in bad fanfiction.

 What do you mean bad fanfiction,I think that is all Star Trek TNG fanfiction.

Author
Time

DuracellEnergizer said:

A sausage sliding into Picard's ear ... I thought something like that could only happen in bad fanfiction.

 What about the one sliding out of Wesley's rear?

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time

DrCrowTStarwars said:

DuracellEnergizer said:

A sausage sliding into Picard's ear ... I thought something like that could only happen in bad fanfiction.

 What do you mean bad fanfiction,I think that is all Star Trek TNG fanfiction.

 Some fanfiction writers have gone on to pen Trek scripts. IIRC, Paramount quietly freaked back when they discovered the author of a couple early TOS novels had written some K/S stories, and had certain passages in one of their books slightly altered.

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time

SilverWook said:

DuracellEnergizer said:

A sausage sliding into Picard's ear ... I thought something like that could only happen in bad fanfiction.

 What about the one sliding out of Wesley's rear?

I think the sausage would be sliding the opposite direction in a fanfic. ;-) 

Author
Time

Thanks for that mental image I didn't need.

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time

SilverWook said:

Thanks for that mental image I didn't need.

 Yeah i think we all know what is going to be in our nightmares for the next.....well..forever.

Weasly Crushers O face,thanks a bunch.

Author
Time

DrCrowTStarwars said:

Yeah the way Warner Brothers treats B5 is a disgrace.  It didn't become as big as Star Trek after five years so they just gave up on it and now the show is slowly dying.  It's why I am backing up my Dvds so that if they ever go i will still have the show somewhere.  Finding the DvDs is becoming hard,that is one reason I would not hold it against anyone if they torrented the show. It's a shame because i think it was remastered B5 would find new viewers.

 I can buy episodes or seasons on my on demand service but won't bother they are incorrectly framed widescreen versions and not the original framing.

Plus they are stuck in SD and not HD.  Cheaply done video effects and all edited on video.  Even if they could do an HD version all the effects would need to be upscaled or replaced.  Or they could just do a fake HD version like farscape and claim the film negatives are lost.

“Always loved Vader’s wordless self sacrifice. Another shitty, clueless, revision like Greedo and young Anakin’s ghost. What a fucking shame.” -Simon Pegg.

Author
Time

There's no way they could get away with that. The tape masters for B5 look terrible! The series needs what TOS and TNG are getting. But I dunno if the original film elements even still exist.

Forum Moderator
Author
Time

Well to be 100% fair a lot of the film for B5 was damaged in an earthquake so that is the reason some of it looks so bad.  Also the show was shot in widescreen because JMS and others saw that coming,it was just staged in such a way that all the action took place in a 4:3 frame. It's my understanding that they only zoom in when they don't have a widescreen copy of a shot due to film being damaged.  I wish we had a group of fans like the Doctor Who restoration team to work on B5 who would look for and find the best film elements and restore them,because B5 deserves to look good.

Oh and as for my remarks about fan fiction,I have written fan fiction myself and it is a great way to get into writing and I have read some stories that are better then the series or movies they are based on and I consider most fan fiction endings(including my own)for Mass effect 3 to be better then what we got in the game. I have written some stuff that people seem to like. I consider that my stuff needs a lot of work to truly be counted as good but I do my best. Still that doesn't stop me from having a sense of humor about myself and others on Fanfiction.net and making the odd joke at our own expense. After all if you can't laugh at yourself,what is the point?

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Oh, there's no doubt that there's good fanfiction out there; the Dark Emperor series by Brendon J. Wahlberg, for example, is one of the best Star Wars stories I've ever read and is a whole lot better than most of the published EU stuff. The good fanfic, unfortunately, seems to be heavily overshadowed by the stuff written by semi-literate teenage girls.

Author
Time

Tobar said:

There's no way they could get away with that. The tape masters for B5 look terrible! The series needs what TOS and TNG are getting. But I dunno if the original film elements even still exist.

 Well if I remember the news from the time this was released on DVD, the live action footage is a new scan of the 35mm negatives, and the special effect footage (or combined live action/special effects footage) is cropped from the 4:3 tape and upscaled to 480i (and further to 576i) but it's true that was a couple of years ago.

Author
Time

pittrek said:

Tobar said:

There's no way they could get away with that. The tape masters for B5 look terrible! The series needs what TOS and TNG are getting. But I dunno if the original film elements even still exist.

 Well if I remember the news from the time this was released on DVD, the live action footage is a new scan of the 35mm negatives, and the special effect footage (or combined live action/special effects footage) is cropped from the 4:3 tape and upscaled to 480i (and further to 576i) but it's true that was a couple of years ago.

 Yeah that is what I heard too. It's a real shame because every once in a while you will come across a scene or even a whole episode that isn't badly damaged and it will look really good.  I really wish there was a market for restoring these episodes for Bluray and redoing the effects shots like TOS.