logo Sign In

4K restoration on Star Wars — Page 206

Author
Time

Yeah but a publication called Star Wars Insider will probably just talk about how it was all for the best and Star Wars was finally changed to match George’s ‘Vision’…

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Dear Mrs. Kennedy!

Do you feel guilty for celebrating the 40th anniversary of Star Wars while shamefully hiding the original cut - the only cut from 40 years ago?

Yours sincerely,

All those waiting for far too long

“People who alter or destroy works of art and our cultural heritage for profit or as an exercise of power are barbarians”

“In the future it will become even easier for old negatives to become lost and be “replaced” by new altered negatives. This would be a great loss to our society. Our cultural history must not be allowed to be rewritten.” --George Lucas on March 3, 1988

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Amano said:

Dear Mrs. Kennedy!

Do you feel guilty for celebrating the 40th anniversary of Star Wars while shamefully hiding the original cut - the only cut from 40 years ago?

Yours sincerely,

All those waiting for far too long

Dear all those waiting for far too long,

No, I don’t. All hail George’s vision!!!

Yours sincerely,
K

Author
Time

We should fund research into parallel dimensions and find the one where Lucas didn’t go nuts, no Special Editions, the original cuts are on Blu-Ray, the Prequels were really good and Carrie is still here.

It seems like people are really embracing the new characters. In fact, the big question people ask me now about Star Wars is, “Are Finn and Poe gay lovers?” And really how the f*ck would I know? My second husband left me for a man, so my gaydar isn’t exactly what you’d call Death Star level quality. ----Carrie Fisher

Author
Time

lovelikewinter said:

We should fund research into parallel dimensions and find the one where Lucas didn’t go nuts, no Special Editions, the original cuts are on Blu-Ray, the Prequels were really good and Carrie is still here.

If this is anyone but Steve Allen, you’re stealing my bit!

Author
Time

2020 is only a few years away…

Author
Time

I hope they don’t wait till 2020 to even comment about it.

Author
Time

The more I think about it, the more it becomes obvious that people simply do not care about seeing the OOT restored. Or at least there aren’t enough people who actually care as much about it as we do.

If the next several years came and went and Lucasfilm continued to say nothing on the subject, that many more people will simply say “I give up, it’s never going to happen.” Over a long enough timeline there simply won’t be anyone left who actually gives enough of a damn to complain about it. Sure, maybe someone at Lucasfilm will see the money-making potential of a release that includes the original versions, but man, they really seem to need a lot of convincing for something that’s guaranteed to rake in the cash.

The biggest imperative is preserving the movies, because one way or another the films elements will eventually disintegrate. Maybe we really should forget about dangling that carrot of “we’re waiting for you to take our money on this,” a strategy that’s failed to get their attention, and appeal to them on the grounds of preserving our cultural heritage.

In other words, we need to shame them into restoring the OOT.

Author
Time

I’m sure Disney appreciates preserving their film assets. They have worked on Song Of The South, even if they’re not going to let anyone see it before 2525. 😉

Forum Moderator

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time

rodneyfaile said:

I hope they don’t wait till 2020 to even comment about it.

I doubt they will comment on it then either

Author
Time

Mocata said:

rodneyfaile said:

I hope they don’t wait till 2020 to even comment about it.

I doubt they will comment on it then either

IMO there are way too many signs pointing to the next major home video release being in 2020 for it not to happen then (Disney getting the rights to ESB and RotJ, 4k UHD players in enough people’s homes, Episode IX having already been released on video the year before).

But even if they continue to hold off so as not to distract from the standalone movie planned for 2020, they’ve already said they’re planning to go on hiatus from new movies before long. Part of me wouldn’t be surprised if 2020 ends up being the hiatus. It would be a natural enough time to do it, after Episode IX and all. But whenever it happens, I think chances are good the relevant people at Lucasfilm will consider a fancy new home video release if only to justify their jobs.

Author
Time

It just seems a shame to fritter away the 40th anniversary though.

Forum Moderator

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time

Fang Zei said:

The more I think about it, the more it becomes obvious that people simply do not care about seeing the OOT restored. Or at least there aren’t enough people who actually care as much about it as we do.

If the next several years came and went and Lucasfilm continued to say nothing on the subject, that many more people will simply say “I give up, it’s never going to happen.” Over a long enough timeline there simply won’t be anyone left who actually gives enough of a damn to complain about it. Sure, maybe someone at Lucasfilm will see the money-making potential of a release that includes the original versions, but man, they really seem to need a lot of convincing for something that’s guaranteed to rake in the cash.

The biggest imperative is preserving the movies, because one way or another the films elements will eventually disintegrate. Maybe we really should forget about dangling that carrot of “we’re waiting for you to take our money on this,” a strategy that’s failed to get their attention, and appeal to them on the grounds of preserving our cultural heritage.

In other words, we need to shame them into restoring the OOT.

The only way the OOT will ever be released is over a certain person’s dead body. I think 2020 will pass by without result. It’s up to the fans to keep these original versions from fading away. Just my opinion.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

When it comes to the general public, I am surprised how many people have no idea there are any changes and that the originals aren’t available,then even more surprised how little they care when I tell them.

While attending Star Wars Celebration and talking to other fans while standing in various lines, I was surprised that none of them cared to even talk about the originals or the possibility of a release.

My Harmy discs become more and more cherished as the years go by.

I can’t believe such an important movie with such a large passionate fan base has ended up like this. It’s like a Twilight Zone episode where I’m the only one who remembers the originals except for a few mysterious people I’ve been communicating with online.

Lucas pretty much succeeded in rewriting history and everyone watched and let him.

Author
Time

rodneyfaile said:

When it comes to the general public, I am surprised how many people have no idea there are any changes and that the originals aren’t available,then even more surprised how little they care when I tell them.

While attending Star Wars Celebration and talking to other fans while standing in various lines, I was surprised that none of them cared to even talk about the originals or the possibility of a release.

My Harmy discs become more and more cherished as the years go by.

I can’t believe such an important movie with such a large passionate fan base has ended up like this. It’s like a Twilight Zone episode where I’m the only one who remembers the originals except for a few mysterious people I’ve been communicating with online.

Lucas pretty much succeeded in rewriting history and everyone watched and let him.

I think there’s still a not-insignificant number of people who fall between those two extremes: people who are big fans of the movies themselves but not hardcore convention goers. I’m talking about the kind of people who will leave a comment on an article about an OOT rumor or reply to someone’s facebook post on the subject.

Someone at Lucasfilm sure seemed to be paying attention to all those comments over the years about how Lawrence Kasdan should’ve written the PT when they hired him for TFA, or the frequency of posts the day of the Disney deal screaming “get Rian Johnson to direct Episode VII” when they eventually hired him for VIII. Sure, you could write off all of that as pure coincidence, but I’d like to think someone on the inside is listening.

Author
Time

Windexed said:

When Disney bought Lucasfilm, they bought EVERYTHING. There’s no contract that says they can’t release the out. For $4 billion, they don’t owe George anything.

Can you post your copy of the contract?

Cheers.

Author
Time

If they can blow off George’s sequel ideas, and bury the release of his last project, it doesn’t seem that the mouse is under any obligations to him at all.

Except maybe skipping the lines at Disneyland. 😉

Forum Moderator

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time

I love the Original films, I grew up with them, so I know your pain. However, I did like certain things that were fixed by George, NOT ALL of them, just a few things. He did go overboard, if you will, I do agree with that. If there could be a way or a person to go in and take certain things out, return the Han shot first, removed the “Nooooo!!!” and kept some other things in there, removed the bad stuff, I would be very happy. I wish there was a way to pick and choose while watching it.

RotJ ending:
Sebastian Shaw Anakin *
Hayden Christensen Anakin

Perhaps they (Disney/Fox) can make this happen someday, who knows. If not, I will have to make my own edit, just like every other fan here.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

George can make all the changes he wants. Just label it as a separate director’s cut, not the only version that should exist.

Author
Time

lurker77 said:

George can make all the changes he wants. Just label it as a separate director’s cut, not the only version that should exist.

George isn’t the director for 66% of the OOT! ;D

Author
Time

doubleofive said:

SilverWook said:

doubleofive said:

I like the short bit being an image leading to the longer letter.

The longer letter would have to go on the front page of the site.

Right. I was going to ask Ady if I could RT it from the SWR account, I’ll ask about FB too.

Have you talked to him yet?

Forum Moderator

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time

GlastoEls said:

lurker77 said:

George can make all the changes he wants. Just label it as a separate director’s cut, not the only version that should exist.

George isn’t the director for 66% of the OOT! ;D

Then call it The George Lucas Edition. Has a nice ring to it.