logo Sign In

Post #43622

Author
jimbo
Parent topic
What is wrong with Return of the Jedi?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/43622/action/topic#43622
Date created
16-Apr-2004, 1:49 PM
Quote

Originally posted by: Darth Chaltab
How about I point out some of AotC's flaws?

1. The dialogue in the Ani/Padme romance is freaking awful.
2. The actors collectively give bad performances even though they aren't bad actors
3. Natalie Portman's monotone speach is only slightly less annoying/ then it was in TMP but thankfully less frequent
4. Why am I numbering them?
5. CG is used in nearly every shot, including many in which it isn't needed.
6. The CG army at the end looks incredibly fake.
7. Nearly every one liner is painfully unfunny
8. Haden Christiansen is topless in bed and screaming in a bad acting mode *cringes*
9. Jar Jar Binks isn't as funny as he was in TMP, and that says a lot.

Over all I really enjoyed Attack of the Clones but... this crap is hard to ignore.


1. No it wasn't. It was a great story of love vs duty. A romance for the ages.
2. All preformances were great. Especially Natalie Portmans
3. It establishes her character well
4. No idea
5. No it was only used when needed. It was always needed
6. I didn't even know it was CG. The effects were incredibly well done
7. The "good job" gave me a chukkle but I don't think most were ment to be funny. This is Star Wars not Futurama
8. Something for the ladies. I just ignore it
9. He was only in 5 minutes and it finally gave his character purpose