Originally posted by: klokwerk
My sentiments exactly Darth Chaltab! However, a lot of fan edits exist as a "series". For example MagFan's set. In order to complete it he may feel obliged to do a fan-edit of Episode III. But, from what I've seen/heard/read I believe that III will be the best of the prequels, the darkest SW film and will (I hope) NOT need fan-edits. But, if they are to be done, I'll be curious as to how people go about different things that were already changed in their edits of ep I & II.

None of the fan edits NEED to be done. That's what fast forward and chapter skip buttons are for.

And Magnolia Fan is planning on re-doing the OT as well. Beyond just restoring the theatrical. He's got a plan to make "his vision" of the Star Wars movies, and that involves re-editing Episodes IV-VI to better fit with his edits of I-III. And he's already got plans on how to edit III before he even sees the movie. At this point, quality of the films really has nothing to do with whether he edits or not.

Plus I think it's silly that fans think they're obligated to finish re-editing someone else's movies just for the sole purpose of completing "a set."