I’m amending my list as well to put ANH and ESB on equal ground (before I had ESB coming out ahead, but in the intervening months I’ve come to regret that placement).
ANH - 10
ESB - 10
TFA - 8
ROTJ - 7
TPM - 4
ROTS - 3
AOTC - 3
And since I’ve seen fan edits mentioned in a couple other posts, I’ll note that all of the prequels shoot up to around a 6 if we’re talking about Hal’s versions.