logo Sign In

Post #98939

Author
Commander Courage
Parent topic
Episode II: Shroud of the Dark Side (the TM edit) (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/98939/action/topic#98939
Date created
29-Mar-2005, 7:17 PM
Trooperman, your edit is by far the most extensive yet, and if you can pull it all off, I'd definitely want a copy! But I do have a few questions:

Are you going the MagnoliaFan route with the alien subtitles? If so, since you're already dubbing Anakin, are you going to try to dub Jar-Jar and the Seperatists? Perhaps from other sources as opposed to backwards/foriegn language tracks (which I found to be the weakest aspect of MagnoliaFan's efforts)?

Will it still be "Attack of the Clones" or are you changing the title and opening scroll?

Are there any other signifigant changes you're making that you'd like to share with us at this time?

I'm just a fan edit junkie (in fact I hope to make my own edits someday), so your project really interests me. On that note, when thinking about my own possible edit, I faced a similar dilemma with the droid factory sequence. You can't just edit it all out because something has to get Anakin and Padme from the ship into custody, but you can't really use it without Artoo, and I wanted to just leave the droids on the ship, ending their part in the film with "If they needed our help they would have asked for it." But I really like the music and Anakin has some of his best action there. You seem to have solved all this quite well.