In the past couple of weeks I’ve finally taken the plunge into PT fan edits, and I’m a little surprised at what it’s done to my rankings. I’ve traditionally ranked AOTC at the bottom of my list because in its official form it’s somehow as boring as TPM and as head-scratchingly stupid as ROTS at the same time, but I think it’s been my favorite of the three in both edits of the PT I’ve seen so far (those being L8wrtr’s and HAL9000’s). Now that I’ve seen it with most of the awful stripped away, I think I agree with Harmy’s assertion a while back that it’s got the best story of the trilogy.