I think at this point I’m ready to put TFA above ROTJ. To put it in terms of albums…

Star Wars and ESB are masterpieces, not a bad track on either album.

ROTJ has some of my favorite songs but overall I think TFA is a slightly better collection of songs.

For the PT, Lucas kicked out all previous band members and made three albums without any other creative input. TPM at least felt like the same band was responsible, but some of the songs are just embarrassing. ROTS was an album that tried to hit all the notes from the original band but failed miserably. AOTC was created by putting a bunch of instruments in a trash compactor.