I can see both sides of the argument here and agree that the 2004 Emperor didn’t really work as well as it could have… but I still think at least in concept, the change is harmless. I don’t mind that much that it’s clearly the RotS Emperor and not the RotJ Emperor, as I still find having the same actor portraying him in all the movies to be a step in the right direction, but I can see how that would bother people. And the added dialogue… Yeah no, get that shit outta my face.

Adywan’s edit is clearly the best version of the scene tho.