There are no rules, merely advice to help you avoid making stupid threads.
I disagree with how you are the only one who can provide advice to people.
And this isn’t a stupid thread. These threads were/are good ideas:
- The “I’m Butthurt About Somebody Else’s Opinions/Posts/Whatever” Thread
- The Index Thread for Franchises, General Human Endeavors, and Other Discussion Threads
- Ranking Pizza
- Improving the Diversity of This Forum
You want a HansiG, and you aren’t getting it.
Only two of those threads were good ideas.
I’m assuming you’re going to say Diversity was a bad idea.
I think forced diversity is a bad idea.
And if this thread had came from anybody else, there wouldn’t be so much whining about it.
That’s probably true, but since HansiG’s gone we need someone new to pick on 😛