There are no rules, merely advice to help you avoid making stupid threads.
I disagree with how you are the only one who can provide advice to people.
And this isn’t a stupid thread. These threads were/are good ideas:
- The “I’m Butthurt About Somebody Else’s Opinions/Posts/Whatever” Thread
- The Index Thread for Franchises, General Human Endeavors, and Other Discussion Threads
- Ranking Pizza
- Improving the Diversity of This Forum
You want a HansiG, and you aren’t getting it.
Only two of those threads were good ideas.