Having recently seen TDK and TDKR, I find them to be very overrated. The main thing that irks me is all the talking and exposition. I feel like Christopher Nolan takes the audience for idiots so he as to spell out everything just to make sure it’s shoved down our throats whatever message he’s trying to give.
Also, it tries to balance between realism and fantasy and it often falters. For all the talk about a ‘realistic’ Batman movie the fans talk about, the plot hinges on microwave bombs, planes without wings and radar vision from hacked cell phones. And don’t get me started on that moment when Batman jumps out of a window, grabs Maggie Gyllenhaal and they land on a car with hardly a scratch…
They’re not terrible films, but I don’t understand how fans will point out all the minute plot issues with BvS and give these films a pass.
People get on BvS because it nearly got everything wrong. From how the characters are portrayed to what a miscast Eisenberg was to how stupid Lex’s plan was which hinged on using Doomsday too early (which is a great story they should have saved for later) etc. The only really good thing about the film was Ben Affleck becoming the closest thing to a faithful film adaptation of Batman (with the exception to the whole killing thing) and Gal Gadot. While some will say TDK trilogy is overrated they are at least decently made films whereas BvS is a mess.
EDIT:
I didn’t care for the first Avengers.
Why? It’s a pretty fun movie