Nostalgia of things that came out before I was born? I don’t think so.
Yes. Sounds like it’s your father’s audiopheelie fetishism rubbing off on you, so nostalgia-by-proxy.
Correct. Most audiophile stuff is absolute BS—newsflash, most people can’t tell the difference between a 128kbps MP3 and a 320 kbps file—check out this test for the evidence.
I’m saying most vinyls that come out are superior to their CD counterparts.
You are obviously saying that. And you are wrong, objectively and quantifiably. Because your subjective impressions are colored by the placebo effect and expectation-confirmation bias.
This is why ABX tests are important—you can unpurposefully affect one’s opinion by saying what something is.