They've both received the same treatment, so your point is moot.
"also talking about resolution differences on dvd is irrelevent because this is always dependent on what type of display your viewing the video on."
Funny that you didn't mention these details to begin with. I guess your statement should read "changing ld ripped video to anamorphic will degrade picture detail and sharpness [depending] on what type of display your viewing the video on.."?