logo Sign In

Post #952782

Author
darthrush
Parent topic
Ranking the Star Wars films
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/952782/action/topic#952782
Date created
13-Jun-2016, 2:13 PM

yotsuya said:

Frink, you can’t prove that something is good or bad when it comes to taste. What people think of a movie is their opinion and there is no right or wrong. You can’t prove the PT are bad movies because that would only be proving that you (or others) think they are bad movies. It is all opinion. I don’t think they are fantastic, but I don’t think they are bad or horrible either. All you can prove is that you have problems with them. Seems your biggest complaint with my ranking is that I dislike TFA more than any of the PT. I have some serious issues with it that I find to be a game changer when it comes to rating it. Deride my opinion all you like, yours is still just a different opinion - no more right than mine.

Exactly. Frink doesn’t comprehend that film is subjective. That’s what makes it so fun. Appreciating all opinions. You saying that it’s fine for him to “like a bad movie” proves that you think your opinion is the objective truth. You obviously don’t understand that there is no way to prove a movie is bad. It’s like food: if you don’t like seafood but someone else does, saying “it’s okay that you like that bad food” makes no sense. Film is subjective! Linking an article from someone saying a movie is bad is just another opinion.