@kk650 - Sorry to hear you took my comments so personally. You are far from the only one to take the skintones too far to the yellow. I’ve noticed it is a common problem. I did the same thing myself on my first few attemps at color correction. Since then I have done a lot of comparison between Star Wars and many other films and done some observations of people and I’ve found that I prefer the mid tone, not too red, not too yellow. That is my preference and I believe that is typical of how most films are color graded. Though I have noticed many films where the skin tones are redder and many where the saturation is upped so the skintones are more orange than peach. Skintones have quite a range and in Star Wars it is particularly noticable between Leia and Tarkin’s more pale skin and Luke, Han, and Ben which are darker. You by no means have to agree with me, but I have yet to add any correction that I find to yellow to my go-to version of the films. I still watch the GOUT or the old LD’s when I want good color.

And as for TFA, I find the original film to be oversaturated and the skin tones too red. It was like he was trying to match that ANH blu-ray skintones. Not good. I think you did an excellent job with the skin tones on TFA, but I think the entire film benefits from lowering the saturation as well as bringing down the red in the skintones. Almost felt like he was going for Fuji color instead of matching the OT’s Kodak color.