Quote
Originally posted by: Shimraa
your right you can compare them however you cant say one is better then the other because they were done in different times.
Street Fighter II and Street Fighter III were made at different times. Am I not allowed to compare them and say one is better than the other?
While we're at it, Goldfinger and Tomorow Never Dies were made at different times too, so how come I'm not allowed to compare them? That seems rediculous to me--they're both in the same series, after all.
Or, how about a relevant example--according to you, I'm not allowed to compare the Original Trilogy to the Prequel Trilogy, because they were made in different times with different mindsets. Yea, they were... that's a large part of the reason people didn't like the PT and they're almost universally considered not as good as the OT.
It all comes down to quality. Everything else is irrelevent.
Quote
But the bottem line as i said before is that bakshi's version wasnt complete. so we don't know how good/bad of a adaption it could have been.
Sure we do. The film he released is a good indication of what we would've gotten had he been able to make a full film.