logo Sign In

Post #928587

Author
Jackpumpkinhead
Parent topic
Info Wanted: Mellenium Falcon and TFA
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/928587/action/topic#928587
Date created
13-Apr-2016, 10:02 AM

Hal 9000 said:

Any story changes you have in mind?

just the basics that most people are doing. overall i was very please with the movie but just a few things kinda bothered me. this is a short list of things i was planning:

  • New crawl that mentions the First Order’s possession of the Starkiller, and to make the crawl less personal with names and such
  • remove all hints to Kylo being related to Solo/Skywalker until the end (so the Lor San Tekka convo, Snoke convo, ect.)
  • possibly trim Finn’s reaction to the village and his “friend” being killed (i can understand him becoming overwhelmed, but he is a stormtrooper and you’d think he would be used to death)
  • Cut the line where Kylo calls Vader “grandfather”
  • move the destruction of the Hosnian System to the end after Han dies.
  • possibly muddy up Phasma’s voice. (IMHO her lines sound to clean. Her voice would be distorted like the rest of the stormtroopers)
  • trim some “fan service” scenes
  • cut scene where stormtroopers turn and walk away when Kylo is throwing a temper tantrum
  • depending on how EP8 starts, I may end the movie early when Rey takes off in the Falcon and leave the Luke reveal for EP8 (there have been a few reports that EP8 will start where TFA ended)

as far as the Falcon cannon sounds go, i think i would still like for them to sound the way that they did in ANH since this is the only movie where they are fired.

ANH Bluray:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fBagc1Ww0_Y
TFA:
https://youtu.be/cpLxD_q5eDc?t=73
Official Soundboard:
http://www.starwars.com/games-apps/star-wars-soundboard
Other SFX:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dnS-XMBQbPM
Battlefront sounds the closest to me:
https://youtu.be/TI-MuqVCFpU?t=15

to me the ANH Cannons have a “sprinkler” sound to it, which is usually attributed to the TIE fighter but the sound in TFA has a deep “thwip” sound to it.