logo Sign In

Post #928269

Author
MalàStrana
Parent topic
Filmmaker and New Yorker film critic Richard Brody's thoughts on the prequels.
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/928269/action/topic#928269
Date created
12-Apr-2016, 6:23 PM

TV’s Frink said:

TV’s Frink said:

MalàStrana said:

TV’s Frink said:

imperialscum said:

TV’s Frink said:

And I’m not religious. So what am I?

You are an American.

That’s not a race.

You can be semitic, or armenian, or turkish, or slavs. It’s even possible you can be latin or nordic. I don’t know your genealogy, so please send me a blood sample so I can run a few tests. I’m not sure you really are jewish, regarding your claimed higher IQ (nice article you’ve posted by the way, not racist at all…).

  1. Your opinion of my “Jewishness” is irrelevant.
  2. I claimed a higher IQ? You must be confusing me with this guy.
  3. I will admit to only skimming the article, I was making reference to the genetic study. I’m curious what is racist about it, however, so perhaps you’d like to elaborate.
  4. I’m still waiting for you to explain why ANY of this is relevant to the question of TPM being full of stereotypes.

Still waiting…

Really ? Dude it’s getting late here and the C1 quarterfinals are long over now, so quickly:

  1. I don’t care as a matter of fact of your “jewishness”: you’re the one who talked about it, so don’t if it’s just a fact dropping that does not add anything important to the discussion. Your personal life is personal, don’t share it.

  2. well, ok (I was quoting the article as a matter of fact, “being sarcastic”).

  3. it might not be (i’ll read it entirely tomorrow), I’ll check the methodology and the discussion if I have the time.

  4. why did you talk about Israel and jewish stereotypes in the first place if Watto’s alleged stereotypes have nothing to do with Israel or jewish ? As for Nute Gunray I never thought the guys was an asian space-dude who carries blatant racist stereotypes (but he’s racist against gungans, or “specists” to be acurate). I simply don’t see it. Would Clint say to Nute “Get off my lawn” ? You don’t agree ? Oh, that’s new ! First time ever we don’t agree on something. It was to happen some day I guess.

My final message in this thread. I leave you the floor to continue your crusade…

edit: tell your padawan is not up to the task. By far…