logo Sign In

Post #92641

Author
ADigitalMan
Parent topic
Thought on de-SE'ing the DVD
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/92641/action/topic#92641
Date created
9-Feb-2005, 9:45 AM
Womble is interesting with its effects. Remedial though they are, they are effective for basic projects. The wipes and transitions are nice, but don't have soft edges. If they add that, I'll be the first to sing its praises as an affordable tool for rank amateurs like myself. What I've noticed is that it only re-encodes the portion of the video that has been affected (I could say "effected" and not be using the wrong word) when it creates the new stream. It's really interesting that way.

Its audio tools are worse though. You definitely have to have the same audio bitrate and you cannot do any crossfading, else it will downmix to stereo and force output to PCM or Layer I or II. But if you're only splicing as I have, then it manages to just splice the audio without changing type or, from what I can tell, recompressing. If the audio splice doesn't sound good where the video splice is, I've found that sometimes the audio splice point can be moved one direction or the other. It's a creative change, but if it makes a better transition, so be it. I ended up needing to do this both at the Dewback removal and the Jabba removal specifically. On the latter, Kenobi's dialogue would have been trimmed, which would not be good.

This isn't a great edit in the end, but it isn't bad either. Feedback on the finished product from you all is what I'm looking forward to most of all. (At least I'm not claiming I've made the best version of Star Wars ever! )