It’s so hard to say: ANH is funnier, ESB is deeper, both are epic. 10/10 for each. I tend to rank ESB higher than ANH but I think they in fact share the same gold medal.
edit:
So, I would change my list (may still change since I’m running a marathon while waiting TFA to be officially released on blu ray):
- ESB & ANH
- ROTJ
- Clone Wars, Volume 1&2 (Tartakovsky)
- ROTS (Hal9000’s)
- TFA
- TPM (Hal9000’s)
- AOTC (Hal9000’s)
- ROTS (theatrical)
- The Clone Wars (my own best of 35 episodes, ending with the final 4-part Ahsoka-centric arc)
- Rebels (my own best of, working progress since the series still airing)
- TPM (theatrical)
- AOTC (theatrical)
It’s crazy how similar your views are to mine especially with the comparison of Hal9000’s edits to the theatricals. I would have just put ROTJ tied with ROTS (Hal9000)