Well I’m not posting the majority of things I’m changing because the edit I’m making is for myself. If you’re making an edit for people to see I think it’d be best to listen to the people. No?
Also, you really should keep Rey’s theme though. There is no way in fuck you can tell me that it’s not a great piece of music and doesn’t fit her character.
Well, I expected more enthusiasm, but I guess that’s my fault. But making an edit for people to see doesn’t automatically mean you take every piece of consideration over your gut instinct. Suggestions and feedback are fantastic, and great for shaping the edit as a whole, but if the edit is something you want to see, you just do it. I’m not going to leave the original music in. It’s going. Simple.
Eh, I say do what you want to do. There are edits out there that appeal to the masses, because some films are so flawed that it’s hard to disagree with the changes.
But there will be folks who are outliers, like you wanting to take out good parts of TFA or Scott wanting to add crappy parts back to the PT. Even if you’re the only person who ever watches it, I say go for it. You’ll learn about editing techniques and maybe have a change of heart for some decisions if you see they don’t work.
I disagree with almost every idea of yours, but you’re 100x better off than someone who instead spends his time begging others to make changes for him. Especially when they’re changes that interest no one else.