Don’t know what the hell I was thinking when I made this thread almost six years ago now. Today it’s

ESB
ANH
ROTS
ROTJ
TFA
AOTC
TPM

I know, I know, Sith over Jedi is bad. But I really hated the 2nd death star, if they didn’t have that then it might honestly be my favorite. The Emperor/Vader/Luke scene is probably my favorite scene in the saga and it’s a perfect conclusion (for the first six films at least). I go back and forth.

EDIT: Added in The Force Awakens. I really thought it was a fantastically made film, and from a film making perspective, it’s top 3 IMO. But I ranked ROTJ low because of the 2nd superweapon, a 3rd superweapon for the 2nd movie in a row is just ridiculous. It showed up, blew up a planet we don’t know/care about, and was destroyed. It’s just too repetitive at this point, hopefully the story can actually move forward now without some big pointless superweapon.