I am very torn currently about how one of the most important chapters of star wars is best handled. So I have been switching my mind condtantly about how these three things might be changed:

-Anakin and obi WANs initial verbal conservation (not the padme convo). I first liked to see as much cut out as possible and liked L8wtr or Hal’s but then I thought that the “sith deals in absolutes” is very strong and I’d rather have 2011 version. Still torn on what would be best cut of this scene?
-The “I have failed you Anakin…” Convo. Q2 and Hal kept it, Kerr and L8wtr cut it. Even though Anakin quite blatantly expressed his feelings I love how Obi Wans “well then you are lost” is delivered in a fashion of frustration and denial where even he starts to realize how much the Jedi screwed this whole thing up but then again it kills the fights momentum and the dialogue for the most part isn’t all that stellar. Very torn and thoughts here would help on what you like best.

and you have the final part of the battle with obi wan attaining the high ground. The 2011 blu Ray was nice because it kept all of Obi WANs speech during immolation scene. Besides that though I may like how L8wtr cut it best.

Those are three almost essential scenes that I feel very torn apart on and your input on which edit handled each of these scenes best would be awesome!