I don’t think moderators are here to regulate our opinions.
Anyways for my own preference I splice together multiple fanedits. For ep1 I use Q2s as a base and splice in Hals to remove gungan city, to restore the sidious scenes, and flesh out parts of Q2s that move a bit too fast.
For ep2 I just use q2 for the most part.
For 3 I switch between Hal and l8.