I prefer my videos looking clean, but not digital clean. So I guess I lean more in the mverta direction.
I know I’ve gotten a little flak around here for saying I like to scrub some (but not all) of the grain from a video. Scrub it so the grain isn’t all in your face, but leave a bit so it doesn’t look like it was shot on a computer. And I’m not a fan of dirt and scratches either - same reason I tend to prefer tapes to records, because tapes didn’t degrade in that way, like records do.
I think there’s a happy medium.