Yeah, that would be a good one. Perhaps it just needs the right kind of work done to it, but I don’t see the TN1 scan as a major upgrade to that shot. Seems a bit out of focus, actually. I wonder if the image quality bothers you, Harmy, or the animation, since I think you hand-animated that one?

If I could, I would upgrade the establishing shots of the squadron and S-foils shot, etc. But the light leak issue of this LPP scan just bugs me too much to use in those iconic shots (it messes with the ships’ engines). Hopefully you’ll be able to get Poita’s LPP scan or something for those ones (and others).

In general, I’m not messing with the shots you rotoscoped since you’ve got some high quality elements in there. The shot of Luke climbing into the X-wing is an exception. Slight downgrade in quality of the tip of the X-wing and hanging cables in exchange for an enormous upgrade in the focus of the shot. The light leak has a small effect on the light fixtures in this scene. But oh well. Other than that, the image quality and color in this scene are among the best in the LPP scan I think.

edit: Just saw your edit. Wow! That would be a huge honor. I can take another look at it, but I’m really not sure I can pull it off. Will see how it goes.