Well, I’ll decide it later, when I’m finished watching the movie (it may take a while). I took a look to the arrival on Naboo extended scene (I haven’t seen the film in years, even when the blu ray got released I merely checked a few scenes and then played frisbee with the disc) and… gosh… I forgot how terrible the acting and the dialogues were… the Coruscant part is way better now (Anakin is notably less a whiny piece of ****) but when it comes on Naboo, it’s still really painful (hopefully the kamino scenes are still cool enough). Curiously when the scene is back to the theatrical version the picture quality stays low. Why didn’t you use the HD material of the original version here ? (sorry if you have already explained your choice).

(I remember in France some papers stated when it was released in 2002 that “ATTACK OF THE CLONES is as good as THE EMPIRE STRIKES BACK… maybe even better” … well… ok…) (3.5/5, I still don’t get it : http://www.allocine.fr/film/fichefilm-29014/critiques/presse/)