logo Sign In

Post #907160

Author
towne32
Parent topic
DESPECIALIZED EDITION QUALITY CONTROL THREAD - REPORT ISSUES HERE
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/907160/action/topic#907160
Date created
11-Feb-2016, 10:29 PM

McGayver said:

REPORT-SW-v2.5
chapter 47
01:46:49 - 01:46:50

there is a very sudden change in the trench after a flash of white light. It seems that the first trench is the original version of the film and the second special edition.

It actually seems like this is a spot where they fused two different model shots (and either two models: a far trench and a close trench) together. It’s that way on the LPP too. If you look at the squares present on the far side of the trench, one of them will have no smaller structures pre-flash, and suddenly be populated post-flash. The flashes were clever tricks to fuse takes. And fortunately they left it alone in the SE. Harmy’s version doesn’t have any color or contrast inconsistency at this point, as far as I can tell.

As for Neverar’s comment on the lighting pre/post SE, I’m not sure. I think the differences in the shadows are mostly due to the fact that these are different (or altered) models, and not precisely the same angle or lighting either. They match decently, all considered.