logo Sign In

Episode II: The Gathering Storm — Page 4

Author
Time
 (Edited)

fishmanlee said:

you know couldnt sombody make...a....sp-special edition? by observing the original and editing together a High Quality reproduction?

Someone certainly could try to cut it together in the same manner.  But most people who are willing to do that much work want to make their own cuts too.

Author
Time

Slumberland here (my original account is lost to the sands of time).

I'm just stupid enough to trying recreating these with the source elements that are now available.  Maybe even go a bit further.  Don't tell my wife though.  We'll see.

I still very much enjoy them, but yeah, they're great for iPad viewing... not so much for modern TVs.

Author
Time

Holy carp!

 

Hi there Slumberland :-)  This edit was one of the earliest prequel edits I watched, and I thought it was really well done.

Author
Time

Thanks! I do like to think that, at the very least, I showed that you can get those two-headed announcers out of the picture, and end TPM before the parade. The prequels almost work if you can get the characters to stop talking!

Author
Time

hi, this is a bit of a "hail mary" - i was hoping to get the slumberland edits for parts 1 to 3, but the pirate bay seeds are dead. can anyone re-seed them?

thanks in advnace

Author
Time

I am so ready to do these in HD and BETTER but I’m super into reincorporating some of the deleted scenes that aren’t on the blu-rays and finding the best possible version of these for upscaling (namely PAL versions of the bonus materials) is a real stumbling block for me.

Author
Time

Little Nemo said:

I am so ready to do these in HD and BETTER but I’m super into reincorporating some of the deleted scenes that aren’t on the blu-rays and finding the best possible version of these for upscaling (namely PAL versions of the bonus materials) is a real stumbling block for me.

Hopefully in just a couple of weeks I can put out what I used for my edits (Episodes I and III upscaled by DrDre, II by me using similar methods).

I know I’ve made some very poor decisions recently.

Author
Time

Did you and Dre start with the PAL versions as the source? Did it make a difference?

Author
Time

No, just the NTSC DVDs that I have. Hadn’t even considered using the PAL.

I know I’ve made some very poor decisions recently.

Author
Time

I think I’ve managed to snag a Region 2 copy of TPM… we’ll see if those extra 94 lines of vertical rez mean anything.

Author
Time

Are the 2.0 sound that goes with these edits Pro-Logic compatible or are they simple downmixes? If they are DPLII I would be willing to sync HD sources with the original audio file, since audio work (to me anyway) is a billion times more frustrating than video.