Hayden’s acting has improved a little since AOTC, but not much. Padme’s character is utterly wasted as a soppy midwife. The lightsaber fights lack tension, apart from the start and end of the Mustafar duel, which is quite emotional. Grievous is horrendous. Yoda has even more cringeworthy “cool” lines. The romance is pushed back, but when it emerges it is just as horrible as ever. The script is pretty garbage. The CGI, apart from Coruscant and Mustafar’s environments, is pretty obvious. It’s not the worst film ever, by far, but it still fails as a film. 4.5/10.