The EU is so diverse that you’re asking people to make a huge array of choices. I kind of hate most of the EU ideas, like Giant Evil Insects and absolutely everything about and related to Starkiller, but then I like Mara Jade, and would love to see Shannon McRandle in a cameo in one of the next films.

If forced to make a choice, I’d say ST, but really the whole mass of threads comprising the EU are too numerous and disparate to treat as an entire half of a binary question, especially when canon has fluctuated a lot over the last decade.