Yeah I get your point now. Oh and I wasn’t saying that you were calling the movie garbage, I was being sarcastic about my own taste in films. That doesn’t always translate very well into print but being sarcastic about myself tends to be how my sense of humor runs, sorry about that.

I have read the Tin Tin comics and i will grant you the film isn’t the same animal as the comics, but then again I don’t think it is any more farther removed from it’s source then the James Bond films are from the novels they are based on so I really enjoyed it for what it was and to me it had the heart and pace that KOTCS lacked. Maybe it is more in line with the film serials Indy is based on then any of the Indy films ever were and I just can’t see it because I have seen some of the serials as many times as the Indy films, all I know is that for me it proved that Spielberg can still tell a classic adventure story.

Still i can understand your point of view, I just don’t see it myself. To me it just doesn’t feel that far removed from Last Crusade or Temple of Doom. Granted those were both sillier then Raiders, but I still think they are good films but I know a lot of people don’t.