Wexter said:
No, that is the unlikely happy ending for the main character. It happens in movies (the original Star Wars for example). Star Wars is and always has been best enjoyed if you suspend your disbelief as much as possible. Implausibilities and strokes of luck have always been a huge part of this franchise. To me, it makes no sense to criticize a Star Wars film for having implausible plot.Implausible. Complex. These are not the words you are looking for.
The word is inconsistent. The story is not consistent with its own internal logic. That is the problem.
And what internal logic would that be? Is there a Star Wars rule saying that a powerful dark side user cannot be under any circumstances bested by an unlikely opponent? I haven’t read all the books, so I wouldn’t know…