I pictured Anakin as a masculine, grown man, age 30 or so, with a beard, much shorter hair than someone like Hayden, already a fully trained Jedi, noble, respected, perhaps a bit more on the quiet side and hard to get to know. Obviously trained by Obi-Wan and the two must have been close.
In my Star Wars universe, that is still younger Anakin, and the prequels don’t exist.