logo Sign In

Post #89111

Author
Darth Simon
Parent topic
Empire of Dreams - what was your imagined Star Wars story...
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/89111/action/topic#89111
Date created
24-Jan-2005, 4:36 AM
YodaIYF, thanks, glad to know you enjoy my ideas...i really like addition to the scene as well...the irony and symbolism that could be worked into that would be amazing. I mean it would basically be an outward representation of the struggle that Anakin/Vader has inwardly (this is really only presented later on in ROTJ, so if you watch OT then PT it would be one of those 'oh, man, i never realized that' type scenes.

though this throws the whole 'Curse of the blue saber' thing out of wack. But at the same time it shows that Vader has not yet been able to destroy all of Anakin (or can if you analyze it). Thinking about it though, i wonder if this later detracts from the scene in Empire where Luke fights Vader using his father's lightsaber. What do you guys think? while it would make a cool scene how would it work when it gets analyzed (as you know it would be if the movie were made this way)? Is there a way to do something similar (have Anakin (through his saber or something else) 'save' Obi-Wan from Vader) without taking away from the Father-Son dual that uses Anakin's/Vader's saber? Id be interested to see what people think on this, and if they think that it actually would detract from this scene.

-Darth Simon