imperialscum said:
it simply does not fit his character. As I pointed out in that discussion, Vader never looses his temper beforeYou must have forgot the very first scene in Star Wars.
Plus the time he killed Admiral Ozzel.
When he killed Ozzel it wasn’t anger at all. It was a witty remark delivered with a calm voice.
As I already said in the previous discussion, “Tear the ship apart…” is the only instance in the span of entire trilogy where Vader raised his voice. So there this one instance versus so many in which he acts extremely calmly. Trying to prove the rule by a single exception is extremely unreasonable, especially in light of overwhelming opposite evidence.
So it is much more reasonable to try to explain the outlier (single exception). It could simply be that he raised the voice as he wanted to be heard by his soldiers across the ship.