Yeah that’s fair. I think the edit is just not for me, but judging be FE.org reviews you’ve definitely created an edit that strikes a chord with a lot of people.

Personally, EPIII has always been my favorite prequel (EpII is my least favorite). That said, It’s a film filled with a lot of extreme and heightened moments, which under GL’s hands can sometimes be really dramatic (The birth of Vader and the delivery of the twins, the opera scene) and sometimes really corny and over the top (The Palpatine face scarring scene, most of Anakin’s dialogue in the Mustafar duel, NOOOOO!). It is the prequel film where the “sith hits the fan” (pun intended), and in that sense it avoids one of the major problems of the first two films (being boring/feeling inconsequential), but brings with it another problem (having some of the most over the top/campy moments in the entire trilogy).

Basically, this is a film that I have a begrudging affection for, and I haven’t really seen an edit yet that satisfies me, so I will probably just “shut up and do it” and make my own.