I actually agree with this. Keep in mind I haven’t watch your RotS just yet however what I love about your edits is that aside from being very well done all your changes have been thoughtful and you keep the original movies as unchanged (in plot) as possible which makes it an easy replacement for the actual movies and less of a fun experiment edit, one and done.

I’m sure I will appreciate the Padme lives and the fact that it makes Sidious even more manipulative and vicious. However It it really the biggest change (a 180 change) that you’ve made and it could be contradicted in TFU, or upcoming material.

Now keep in mind nothing would stop you from changing the edit if that day comes though no matter what your decision is.