logo Sign In

Post #79469

Author
skeg64
Parent topic
Censorship of the original films
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/79469/action/topic#79469
Date created
27-Nov-2004, 7:43 AM
I agree with Daniel. At least I think I do. Sometimes I can't tell though.

I just don't think he's very good at arguing, that's all.

Daniel, don't even start to make this a racial thing because that is a)irrelevant b)deconstructive and c)offensive.

-edit-

Their argument crumbles anyway. MBJ and Zion both agree that 1. you can't notice the changes, and 2. they don't matter. They seem to use this argument in the sense that we should therefore accept the changes. But in doing so it raises two counter questions. 1. if you can't notice the changes, why put them there? and 2. if they don't matter than why does it matter so much to have them edited?


This, however, is a good point, and one that MBJ and Zion have not presented an argument against.

@MBJ:
I'm not saying you hate the films. I agree that spending time, money and effort on them is showing how you love the films. But if you feel the need to change them, that is showing you don't like them the way they are. Perhaps I'm missing something - why else would you change them?

And I didn't realise you were going to work on a theatrical version, that's certainly great news.